Your accountant sends the year-end package. Net income: $186,000. You feel something between relief and confusion, because you know what is in the operating account, and it is nowhere close to $186,000. It was $31,000 in January and it is $36,000 now. Profitable but no cash in the bank: either the books are wrong, or somebody took the money.
The short version: neither. The books are almost certainly right, and nobody took anything. Profit and cash answer two different questions, and six specific things sit between them — accounts receivable growth, loan principal, equipment purchases, owner distributions and estimated taxes, prepaid expenses, and supplies on the shelf. Every one of them consumes real cash and none of them appears as an expense on your profit and loss statement. Run the reconciliation once and the mystery disappears permanently: in the composite below, $186,000 of net income turns into a $5,000 increase in the bank account, and every dollar of the difference is accounted for. Once you can see the six leaks, you can manage them.
Profitable but no cash in the bank: why it happens
Your P&L is built on accrual accounting. It records revenue when you earn it and expenses when you incur them, regardless of when money actually moves. That is the right way to measure whether the practice is economically sound — it is why you can compare March to April without a payer’s payment schedule distorting the picture.
But it means the P&L is deliberately silent about timing. It does not care that a claim you produced in November gets paid in February. It does not care that $61,000 of your loan payments went to principal. It does not care that you wired the IRS $74,000 in April. Your P&L measures performance; only the balance sheet and the cash flow statement explain what happened to the money. Most practice owners in Rhode Island and eastern Massachusetts are handed the first and never shown the other two, which is the whole problem in one sentence. If your monthly package is a P&L and nothing else, that is the first thing to fix — and it is a big part of what separates a bookkeeper from a CFO advisor.
The one-page reconciliation your P&L will never show you
Below is an illustrative composite: a two-physician primary care practice in Providence collecting roughly $2.4 million a year, after both owners’ salaries are already in the expense line. These are constructed planning figures — not a real client, and not a benchmark.
| Line | Amount | Why it moves cash but not profit |
|---|---|---|
| Net income per the P&L | $186,000 | The starting point |
| Add back depreciation and amortization | +$22,000 | An expense that took no cash this year |
| Growth in accounts receivable | −$47,000 | Earned and billed, not yet collected |
| Increase in accounts payable | +$6,000 | Incurred, not yet paid |
| Equipment down payment | −$18,000 | Capitalized, not expensed |
| Loan principal repaid | −$61,000 | Only the interest hits the P&L |
| Owner distributions and estimated taxes | −$74,000 | Never an expense of the business |
| Prepaid expenses and supplies | −$9,000 | Paid this year, expensed later |
| Actual change in cash | +$5,000 | What the bank statement shows |
$181,000 of the $186,000 never touched the profit and loss statement. That is not an accounting error. That is what the P&L is designed to leave out.
Where the $186,000 actually went
Accounts receivable growth — the biggest leak in most practices
If you produced more this year than last, and your payer mix and collection speed stayed flat, your A/R balance grew. That growth is profit you have earned and financed on the payer’s behalf. A $47,000 increase means $47,000 of your net income is sitting in a claims queue.
The trap is that growth makes this worse, not better. A practice growing 15% a year is permanently lending a larger balance to its payers. That is survivable when margins are good and fatal when they are thin. Rhode Island’s prompt-payment statute, R.I. Gen. Laws § 27-18-61, does put a clock on clean claims — but a clock only helps claims that were submitted clean and are being worked. Pull an A/R aging report this week and look at everything past 60 days. That is the fastest cash in your practice, and specialist bookkeeping for healthcare practices should be putting that report in front of you every month without being asked. For dental practices the same problem shows up as a gap between production and collections, which is worth reading alongside this.
Loan principal and equipment — real cash, invisible on the P&L
Your practice loan payment is $6,400 a month. Your P&L shows maybe $1,300 of it, because only interest is an expense. The other $5,100 reduces a liability on the balance sheet — a use of cash that is completely invisible in the report you actually read. Across a year that is $61,000 in this composite.
Equipment behaves the same way. Buy a $90,000 unit with $18,000 down and finance the rest, and the P&L shows only depreciation. The $18,000 left the account; the loan payments start next month; neither is reflected the way you would expect. The federal tax deduction can be generous and, in Rhode Island, is largely deferred at the state line — but a deduction is not cash, and it never was. We work through that trap in detail in the ROI framework for buying a CBCT; coordinate the timing with your tax planning before you sign, not after.
Distributions and estimated taxes — money that was never really yours
This is the one that stings. If your practice is an S-corp, the profit is taxed on your personal return whether or not it ever leaves the business account. So you take distributions to cover the tax, and those distributions are not an expense — they are a reduction of equity, invisible on the P&L.
The IRS expects that money quarterly: April 15, June 15, September 15, and January 15 of the following year. The safe harbor is 90% of the current year’s tax or 100% of last year’s — 110% of last year’s if your prior-year AGI was over $150,000, which describes most practice owners reading this. Miss it and you owe penalties on top of a bill you already could not see coming. Whether an S-corp is even the right structure is worth revisiting on its own terms — see RI LLC vs. S-corp for Rhode Island businesses.
Prepaids and supplies — small, quiet, and constant
The annual malpractice premium paid in January. The software renewal. The extra case of supplies ordered because the price was good. Each is cash out now and an expense spread over months, or sitting on a shelf until used. Individually trivial, collectively another $9,000 — and in a practice that stocks meaningful inventory, considerably more.
How to run this yourself in twenty minutes
You need three things: this year’s P&L, and a balance sheet as of the first and last day of the period. Then:
- Start with net income. Straight off the P&L.
- Add back depreciation and amortization. Non-cash expenses. This is the only line that moves in your favor.
- Subtract the increase in A/R (or add the decrease). Compare the two balance sheets.
- Add the increase in accounts payable (or subtract the decrease).
- Subtract prepaid and inventory increases. Same comparison.
- Subtract every dollar of loan principal. Beginning loan balance minus ending balance.
- Subtract equipment purchased with cash and all owner distributions.
Your answer should land within a few hundred dollars of the actual change in your bank balance. If it does not, your books have a problem and that is the real finding. Practices in Newport and Woonsocket come to us every month having never once tied their profit to their bank account — and the reconciliation is usually where the real issue surfaces.
What to change in the next 90 days
- Add the two missing reports. A balance sheet and a statement of cash flows, monthly, alongside the P&L. Non-negotiable. Start with books that actually produce them.
- Work the aging every week. Anything past 60 days gets a name attached to it and a follow-up date.
- Fund taxes separately. Move a fixed percentage of collections into a second account every month. The April surprise stops being a surprise.
- Forecast thirteen weeks out. Payroll, debt service, estimated taxes, and the trough week. Cash problems are visible weeks ahead if anyone is looking — start with our free 13-week cash flow forecast template, which is the core of CFO advisory work.
- Know your real numbers. Collection rate, days in A/R, overhead percentage, and loaded payroll as a share of collections. You cannot manage what nobody reports. The 16 parts of your business is a useful map of where to look.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my practice profitable but has no money in the bank?
Because profit and cash are measured differently. Six things consume cash without appearing as expenses on your P&L: growth in accounts receivable, loan principal repayment, equipment purchases, owner distributions and estimated taxes, prepaid expenses, and inventory. Reconcile net income to the change in your bank balance and every dollar will be accounted for.
Does depreciation mean I have more cash than my P&L shows?
Yes, on that line alone. Depreciation is an expense that took no cash this year, so it gets added back when you reconcile profit to cash. But it is usually the only line moving in your favor, and it is almost always swamped by A/R growth, loan principal, and distributions moving the other way.
Why doesn’t my loan payment show up on my P&L?
Only the interest portion is an expense. The principal portion reduces a liability on your balance sheet. On a $6,400 monthly payment, as little as $1,300 might appear on the P&L while $5,100 quietly leaves your account. Over a year that gap alone can exceed your entire reported net income.
How much cash should my practice keep on hand?
There is no authoritative benchmark for this, and anyone quoting one precisely is guessing. As a planning rule of thumb, most advisors point at somewhere between one and three months of operating expenses, with practices carrying heavy payer A/R or seasonal volume sitting at the higher end. The better question is not the target but the trough: run a 13-week forecast and find your lowest projected week.
Do I need a CFO or just a better bookkeeper?
If your books are late, wrong, or missing a balance sheet, you have a bookkeeping problem and should fix that first. If your books are clean and you still cannot answer “where did the money go,” that is a CFO question. The distinction matters — see CFO advisor vs. fractional CFO, what the role actually looks like day to day, the seven signs it is time, and what it costs in Rhode Island.
Bottom line
“I’m profitable but I have no money” is not a mystery and it is not a sign that something is broken. It is the predictable result of reading one report that was never designed to answer the question. Net income tells you whether the practice works. The balance sheet and the cash flow statement tell you where the money went. You need all three, monthly, or you are flying on one instrument.
Run the reconciliation once. Twenty minutes, three reports. When you can name all six leaks and size them, you stop guessing — and you can start deciding which one to fix first.
Not sure where your money went last year? Bring us your P&L and two balance sheets and we will build the reconciliation with you on a call — you will leave knowing the number. Book a free 30-minute consultation, or read more about working with a CFO advisor in Rhode Island.
General information for Rhode Island and Massachusetts practice owners, not tax or legal advice. Dollar figures are an illustrative composite — not real client results or industry benchmarks. Confirm current thresholds and deadlines with your CPA before acting.
by